i like 3 more. the dynamics in 3 are even more heading forward. the split body coming from the lightbar, crossing the wheelarch plus the rear hanging diffusor break the dynamic in the back little too much
Berk KaplanCreator
thanks for the feedback! :)
1326164634400
Berk, you don't know me but I've been following you for some time. I've been a professional car designer for over 50 years, and taught Trans Design at CCS for 8 years. I particularly enjoyed your comments on this latest video regarding dealing with criticism . As you pointed out, a designer has to deal with criticism, positive or negative. It's part of the job. If you can't deal with criticism, you should probably find another profession. It can be brutal at times, but that's why we have such thick skins.
To your point, as long as you counter criticism in a constructive, positive manner, no one can ever fault your intensions. One has to understand the source of the critique and the agenda if any, consider it, then move forward. I've spent my entire adult life dealing with critiques of some form or another. It's part of the 'deal'.
Sometimes we can't see our work from a different perspective. It helps to get a fresh eye on the proposal. Then as a professional you can decide what if anything to do about critical comments. As far as the internet goes, I certainly would never use that as a serious source of commentary.
So, thank you for what you're doing. Keep helping the young aspiring designers.
Berk KaplanCreator
Wow, reading your comment really made me proud. Thank you very much your kind words and I really appreciate it!
I totally agree with you, I have tiny experience compared to yours :) but I know what you mean, this thick skin comes with some years.. As you said "one has to understand the source of the critique" and this is very very difficult for a design student or younger designers. They don't know yet, and many of them unfortunatelly lose the passion for design for that reason. On the other hand, stronger ones survive..
Thank you again for your comment, you made my day.
4 comments
i like 3 more. the dynamics in 3 are even more heading forward. the split body coming from the lightbar, crossing the wheelarch plus the rear hanging diffusor break the dynamic in the back little too much
thanks for the feedback! :)
Berk, you don't know me but I've been following you for some time. I've been a professional car designer for over 50 years, and taught Trans Design at CCS for 8 years. I particularly enjoyed your comments on this latest video regarding dealing with criticism . As you pointed out, a designer has to deal with criticism, positive or negative. It's part of the job. If you can't deal with criticism, you should probably find another profession. It can be brutal at times, but that's why we have such thick skins. To your point, as long as you counter criticism in a constructive, positive manner, no one can ever fault your intensions. One has to understand the source of the critique and the agenda if any, consider it, then move forward. I've spent my entire adult life dealing with critiques of some form or another. It's part of the 'deal'. Sometimes we can't see our work from a different perspective. It helps to get a fresh eye on the proposal. Then as a professional you can decide what if anything to do about critical comments. As far as the internet goes, I certainly would never use that as a serious source of commentary. So, thank you for what you're doing. Keep helping the young aspiring designers.
Wow, reading your comment really made me proud. Thank you very much your kind words and I really appreciate it! I totally agree with you, I have tiny experience compared to yours :) but I know what you mean, this thick skin comes with some years.. As you said "one has to understand the source of the critique" and this is very very difficult for a design student or younger designers. They don't know yet, and many of them unfortunatelly lose the passion for design for that reason. On the other hand, stronger ones survive.. Thank you again for your comment, you made my day.